Hostels are rated using the Modified Golden Backpacker Method, devised and refined by Dan Frommer and the Golden Backpacker at the Backpackers Hostel in Lucerne, Switzerland. Assessments are objective, subjective, standardized, irregular, opinionated and irreverent. If you disagree with anything, let us know.
How It Works
Ratings are based on a 10 point score, 10 being the greatest. Points are based on the following criteria:
Location, Location, Location (3 points maximum). Hostels should be easily accessible from the city’s main train terminal(s) via foot or public transportation (1 point), should offer easy access to the city’s main attractions (1 point) and should be close to food, nightlife and culture (1 point). This is the most subjective category, but we’re okay with it.
Security (1 point maximum). Hostels should have reasonable security, such as 24 hour reception, locking room doors, and/or should provide lockers or similar secure luggage storage, ideally for free (1 point).
Facilities (2 points maximum). Hostels should provide a clean, well-maintained kitchen for communal cooking and laundry machines (dryers not required) or laundry service at a reasonable price (1 point for either) and decent sleeping/living facilities including beds, lighting, toilets and showers (1 point).
Character (2 points maximum). Hostel atmosphere should be informal and friendly. Hostels full of excessive vapidity or those resembling commercial warehouses will be marked down in this area. Hostels should also be conducive to traveler interaction. The best will have a bar or common room/outdoor patio for winding down at the end of a long day.
Value (2 points maximum). Hostels should be appropriately priced based on location, city size, facilities and competition. Bonuses included in the fee, such as ‘free’ Internet and/or breakfast, are considered in this assessment.
Future Improvements
While this system is not perfect, it works for now. Future improvements may give preferential treatment to hostels that offer online booking with immediate confirmation, hostels with no curfew or lockout, hostels with free bed linens, hostels with free Internet access, or a few other parameters. We encourage your comments.